AUDIO

by Archbishop Peter Jensen
Archbishop Peter Jensen's Christmas Message 2011 on the centrality of Jesus to human history
When less is best
Craig Schwarze
July 20th, 2010

It’s funny how often a challenge becomes an opportunity. My rostered drummer was not available for church last Sunday, and I wanted to give my other drummer the week off. I really dislike having music without percussion, so I asked someone else to fill in - a talented muso who hadn’t been on the roster for a while due to family commitments. He told me he was a bit rusty on a regular kit, so he’d bring along his djembe (a simple African drum) instead.

We went for a cut-down, “unplugged” musical ensemble - djembe, piano and acoustic guitar. I suspected it would work well, but it was even better than I’d imagined. There was an organic, rhythmic flavour to the music. It was softer than our usual sound, but the congregation are good singers now, and their voices swelled to fill up the spaces. It was a great morning of singing, as we did Blessed Be Your Name, How Great is our God, Take My Life and It is not Death to Die. I got lots of encouraging feedback later.

Most contemporary churches are trying to make a standard rock ensemble work - but that can be tricky. For some churches, the way forward is to put away the drum sticks, unplug the guitars, and go for something a little more simple and raw…

Robin Grant Jordan    21 July 2010 6:33pm
We also use djembe at the Journey. Congas and bhodran--Irish hand drum--also work well with electric guitar or electric guitar and key board. We have also used electric violin. When we blew the sound system, we have gone acoustic. We have gone accappello too.

Djembe can be used by itself. One song that works well with just African hand drum accompaniment is "All you works of God bless the Lord," a metrical version of the Prayer Book canticle--Benedicite opera omnia--set to the upheat West Indian tune LINSTEAD. The final "bless the Lord" of the refrain can be accented with a hand clap on each syllable.

I also recommend tin whistle, recorder, ulihan bagpipes, mandolin, hammered dulcimer, zither, hand harp, and other folk type instruments. By folk type instruments I am not referring to the old ballads or the folk music of the 1960s or the regional folk music of today but the instruments used in traditional cultures around the world--like the kalimba, or finger piano or the Chinese one string violin. It does not hurt to vary your sound from time to time. Do a plaintive Celtic song. Or a melodious African song with no accompaniment. I find that too many contemporary churches have fallen into a musical rut. They need to diversify!

#2 of 9 top
Craig Schwarze    21 July 2010 9:43pm
Sounds fabulous Robin!

#3 of 9 top
Anthony Douglas    25 July 2010 11:49pm
Sounds excellent, but I do have to ask (without prejudice!)...those songs don't look like they're close together alphabetically ;-) Was this a one-off, or have you found you can tweak your system, now it's been in place for a while? I'm genuinely curious.

#4 of 9 top
Craig Schwarze    26 July 2010 9:31am
Good question..!

The first Sunday of every month, I introduce a new song, which is obviously not in alphabetical sequence. It then gets a four week run, then four weeks off, then another four week run to really make sure the congregation know it. This is why the sequence appears as it does.

#5 of 9 top
Anthony Douglas    26 July 2010 12:11pm
Ah - so Blessed Be Your Name and Take My Life are the 'new' and 'nearly new' in there, and you're up to H/I in the list. That makes sense.

How's it gone, the 4/4/4 method of learning new songs. Do people show any signs of fatigue with it? I've been reluctant to flog any song that hard in the past, but if it does work well, perhaps I should!

#6 of 9 top
Craig Schwarze    26 July 2010 12:34pm
Actually, "Blessed" from the top of the list - we are back to the start.

The 4 week method has worked really well. No-one has said anything critical about it, and we have been doing it for five months. And the improvement in the singing has been really, really noticeable. People really learn the songs these days.

Here's what I suggest you do - just pick one good song and repeat it over 4 weeks, choosing the other songs as you regularly do. First see if anyone notices, and comments. Second, compare how well the congregation sing the song on the first week to the fourth week.

#7 of 9 top
Anthony Douglas    26 July 2010 12:41pm
I've done weeks 1, 2, 4 and 7, so it's not really the first block that would be different - it's the coming back for another round. But I may well give it a go.

#8 of 9 top
Craig Schwarze    26 July 2010 12:45pm
Well, it's only the new songs that I bring back after 4 weeks - I wouldn't do that with a well known song. But by singing it 8 times in 12 weeks, I really feel the tune embeds itself into the congregation.

#9 of 9 top
Robin Grant Jordan    26 July 2010 6:22pm
My experience is that worship leaders, the instrumentalists, and the vocalists are more likely to be bored by repetition of songs than the congregation. Members of the congregation who clamour for something new all the time usually are not singing. They are listening to the band, music group, worship team or whatever you want to call the worship leaders, instrumentalists and vocalists, and worshiping vicariously through them. I have always taken my cue from what Betty Pulkingham wrote in the 1980s. "The role of the 'choir' (a term which she used in a very broad sense to include the worship leaders, instrumentalists and the vocalists, what we now call the band, music group, or worship team) is to release the congregation into praise." You may need to do some teaching about worship in heaven, thousands upon thousands praising the Lamb, and that sort of thing. No listeners in heaven, only praisers! We praise God with our lips on Sundays but our praise of him is reflected in our lives during the week. We do not meet on Sundays to get high on the music but to put our exhultation, magnification, and praise of God into words, glorifying him with our lips as we do with our lives during the week. If your worship team is not releasing the congregation into praise and the congregation is not living lives that praise God, then the worship team might want to look for a new gig.

#10 of 9 top
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.