AUDIO

by Russell Powell
Archbishop Peter Jensen's Christmas Message 2011 on the centrality of Jesus to human history
Stop the gambling tsunami
Jeremy Halcrow
August 30th, 2010

Yesterday was one of those days in the media when a strong theme runs through the news, without anyone actually joining the dots.

From Federal politics to the sporting pages there was a lot of talk about the evils of gambling.

Sadly, even top officials at Cricket Australia seemed resigned to the latest Pakistani cricket bet scandal, including claims Australia's surprise win in the Sydney test was also fixed. Jamie Pandaran in the Sydney Morning Herald looked at the corruption of Pakistani cricket in some depth.

Aussie sport at risk from net bet explosion

Much of the recent problem with international betting scams has to do with the explosion of internet sports gambling.

The issue is far from merely a foreign problem.

Perhaps it was a case of stating the bleeding obvious but earlier this year I predicted there would be many more sports betting scandals due to the growth of 'spot' betting on micro events within a game, which is far easier to corrupt.

The National Rugby League (NRL) has called in NSW Racing chief steward to investigate allegations of fixing in the recent Cowboys versus Bulldogs clash. The allegation focuses on a huge betting plunge on the Cowboys scoring first via a penalty.

While the player who gave away the penalty - Bulldog's forward Ryan Tandy - has denied involvement in the alleged betting scam, NRL officials should be very concerned with the claims the punters in this case were largely the same 'inside traders' that backed the Storm for the wooden spoon just before news of the player payment fraud broke.

Overall, there has been a lack of public attention on the growing symbiotic relationship between corporate sport and the gambling giants.

Indeed, as I indicated in Southern Cross earlier this year, the Storm's corrupted corporate culture appears to have originated in a desire to hide the club's sponsorship links with a big gambling house.

NSW’s gambling addiction, Wilkie and pokies reform

Independent Senator Nick Xenaphon has long championed the need to better regulate the gambling industry, including internet sports betting.

After advice from Xenaphon, new Tasmanian independent Andrew Wilkie has made measures to address problem gambling key items on his check-list for supporting a new Australian Government. (Although its far from the only issue on Wilkie's priority list.)

Given it's extraordinary reliance on gambling taxes, it is no surprise State Labor came out yesterday and rejected measures to tackle problem gambling.

In NSW we have gone backwards since I investigated the issue in 2008 for Southern Cross.

Two years ago the Coalition was at least considering the possibility of reform.

To my great disappointment Opposition treasury spokesman Mike Baird has gone very quiet on gambling reform in NSW in recent years. (Love to hear differently Mike!)

I find myself nodding in agreement with Peter Debnam's lament at the NSW Liberal's small-target approach:

"It means that you actually have to be courageous and you have to lay out your policies… You actually have to say, we’re going to do it. Not just imply that you’re going to do it.’‘

Pokie reform at the State level has been put in the too-hard basket.

So we look to the Feds.

While there seems to be legal questions around the Feds' constitutional right to intervene on the States gaming addiction, Stephen Mayne made an excellent point on Crikey.

The wisdom of the Wilkie/Xenaphon approach is that it looks to address the issue at the (revenue rich) Federal level, argues Mayne.

As the major parties contemplate just how far they push the pokies reform agenda to secure Wilkie's support, it is worth considering. an academic study showing John Howard's guns buyback policy reduced suicides using a fire-arm by 200 a year.
If you can buy back guns and water licences, there is absolutely no reason why you can't buy back pokies licences.
Sure, it will be expensive to compensate State governments, but think of the benefit to those citizens who are currently losing almost $10 billion a year playing the pokies. A whopping $4 billion of those losses are estimated to come from Australia's 100,000 problem gamblers.
No other country on earth has comparable statistics, so why wouldn't Julia Gillard and Tony Abbott take up the challenge and commit to things like the $1 maximum bet as the Productivity Commission recommended?

The churches

In a sense we are all exploiting the suffering of those families who live with a problem gambler, via our State Government's addiction to revenue from problem gambling.

Gambling reform is one of the few issues where the churches could speak with a united and credible voice.

A campaign to reduce problem gambling could unite conservatives with the 'social justice' left.

Plus the churches have public credibility on the issue due to all their community work, which often touches on the fall-out from problem gambling. (If I’m reading their social exclusion report correctly, last year Anglicare in Sydney alone provided emergency relief to 700 households who were in need due to the impact of a gambling addiction).

PHOTO: Mohammad Yousuf and Michael Hussey after the Australia V Pakistan second cricket test match at the Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney, Jan. 6, 2010. (AAP Image/Tim Clayton)

So over to you:

1. What can be reasonably done to reduce problem gambling?

2. Should the Government better regulate betting on 'micro' sports events?

3. Does the Government need to do more to regulate the relationship between big sport and big gaming, given the potential conflicts of interest?

4. Is a complete ban on gambling companies sponsoring sporting teams warranted?

Jeremy Halcrow    31 August 2010 12:00am
TODAY'S NEWS UPDATES

Pokie reform

Clubs rubbish WIlkie's proposal to limit to $1 each pokie bet.

Wilkie confirms pokie reform and Hobart Hospital are his two main priorities for providing support to ALP or L/NP.

Sports betting

Gamblers are migrating from pokies to online sports betting costing State Govts $millions in tax revenue

Why Cricket's statistical complexity makes it so vulnerable to corruption via spot bets

Cowboys players will be interviewed about alleged NRL bet scam plus more details about one of the punters who tried to bet big on the penalty spot bet.

And a reminder of the long history of sports betting scams: Here is the 10 biggest scams.

#2 of 0 top
Jeremy Halcrow    31 August 2010 12:00am
Given all of the above, further Govt regulation of sports betting - particularly spot betting - seems a no brainer to me.

#3 of 0 top
Michael Kellahan    31 August 2010 12:55am
I'd love to see the state governments wean itself off gambling revenue. If it wasn't so financially addicted itself it would be better placed to govern with justice and compassion.
A united Christian voice against gambling would help governments to count the cost in a different way - electorally.

#4 of 0 top
Gareth Richards    31 August 2010 2:30am
I'm an avid Brisbane Lions fan. When you look at the AFLs live matchday website they display the 'live' odds of either team winning from that moment right next to the actual score. I found myself having to explain to my two <10 year old boys why the Lions were beating the Eagles by $4.00 to $1.50!! This coupled with the sad irony of the Lions' Brendan Fevola's gambling addiction further ruining his already troubled life. The AFL doesn't already have enough money without resorting to this??
So yes, I would support a ban on sports/gambling sponsorship.

#5 of 0 top
David Clarke    31 August 2010 4:27am
The focus on the gambling odds being offered was far too prevalent in all the media coverage of the lead up to the election. Gambling and the subtle promotion of it has spread to so many areas of Australian life.

#6 of 0 top
Joshua Kuswadi    31 August 2010 12:02pm
I'm very keen to find out more and think through how to challenge society's, not just state government's fascination with gambling. How can we lobby for attitudinal change similar to what took twenty years for anti-smoking campaign?

#7 of 0 top
Jeremy Halcrow    31 August 2010 11:58pm
Watching this issue for some years, I think Wilkie and Xenaphon are on the right track trying to tackle it at the Federal level for the reason I mention: the Feds have all the $$ in our tax system.

That said NSW is well behind Victoria and SA on addressing problem gambling, with people like Tim Costello and Nick Xenaphon really kicking some goals.

#8 of 0 top
Jeremy Halcrow    01 September 2010 12:01am
I was hoping we'd smoke out some of our conservative libertarian friends so we could discuss whether this is an issue of individual responsibility and big Govt should butt out.

Where is Mr Schwarze when you need him? Love to know your mind Craig :)

#9 of 0 top
Alan Dungey    01 September 2010 11:13am
Speaking from the perspective of the "west wing" of the conservative libertarians, I for one am grateful that Western Australia has no pokies in pubs, and that all parties in this State are pledged to keep things that way. Quiet drinking, conversation, and music flourish.

As for banning spot betting - this would be a complete waste of time, unless you have an extra-powerful national net filter. Perhaps we could invite the Chinese in as consultants to try to show us how to create one.

#10 of 0 top
Jeremy Halcrow    01 September 2010 11:14pm
LOL Allan.

There is not much we can do about betting scams originating in Asia, but the NRL issue appears to be locals. So the question is whether it would help to be regulate Australian companies.

The bigger moral issue is State govts being dependent on revenue from problem gambling mostly via pokies.

#11 of 0 top
Michael Steggles    01 September 2010 11:46pm
I find it horrible, how much gambling is promoted, especially in sport. Live odds updates during league matches, sports betting agencies having spots on radio to deliver the "bets of the week". Radio stations giving out betting vouchers as prizes. The state government relies too heavily on income from gambling. A few initiatives that I would like to see put in place are sponsorhip restrictions, live betting updates during sporting events and advertising restrictions. Gambling addiction is a massive social problem and it is sad to see it ignored when we should be campaigning against it as whole heartedly as we do smoking or drinking. I think churches need to speak more openly to their congregations about a christian perspective of gambling

#12 of 0 top
Michael Canaris    02 September 2010 12:52am
This issue needs a lot of study. Perhaps a special raffle could fund some.

#13 of 0 top
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.