AUDIO

by Archbishop Peter Jensen
Archbishop Peter Jensen's Christmas Message 2011 on the centrality of Jesus to human history
Buy Buy Christmas
Karin Sowada
November 8th, 2011

There is always a sense of relief in my household when the clock ticks past 5pm on Christmas Eve. By that time, the retail frenzy of Christmas is over and one’s mind can start to relax as the holiday season truly begins.

But for some hapless workers, that may be about to change.

The NSW State Government is currently examining proposals to de-regulate shop trading hours on restricted days such as Christmas Day, Boxing Day, Good Friday, Easter Sunday and the morning of Anzac Day.

These are designated public holidays and under current rules, shops are required to be closed, or operate on certain days under restricted trading licenses (the latter allows city department stores to open on Boxing Day and after 1pm on Anzac Day, for example). The overall result is a legal presumption of a retail shutdown across the state on key public holidays, with some automatic exemptions for small shops and the granting of other restricted exemptions. The law surrounding retail trading in NSW is complex and each State has its own regulations.

In September, the Minister for Finance and Services, Greg Pearce MP, announced an inquiry into shop trading provisions and invited submissions, which closed on 24 October. A key part of this inquiry involved an examination of ‘a reduction in the number of restricted trading days under s. 4 of the [Retail Trading] Act.’

It is evident from reading the Inquiry Discussion Paper that there is a great openness to the possibility of further extending trading hours into what has traditionally been times of community and family rest. This is particularly true for Boxing Day and Easter Sunday. The report reveals that city retailers are big on seeking exemptions already. There is also pressure from the tourism industry to ensure that Sydney can deliver a 24/7 retail and entertainment experience for visitors.

From a Christian and broader social perspective, these are troubling developments. All in the name of creating employment and business opportunity.

There is no question that Sydney has become a global city. Easter and Christmas are both peak holiday times for local and overseas visitors. But setting time aside for community rest is a social good and ensures that people are not pressured by employers to work. As a church we would want to ensure this time of community rest and reflection is preserved, and that the Christian message of these periods is not lost in more displays of unnecessary mass consumption. Moreover, the further extension of trading is a form of bracket creep; in time there will be inevitable calls for trading on Good Friday. At that point, why bother with Easter holidays at all?

There are plenty of days for shopping and going about one’s business in the rest of the year. In addition, the enthusiasm with which Australians have adopted internet shopping means that the store-based retail experience has less appeal anyway. An enforced break from this activity does everyone good, whether people believe in 'the reason for the season’ or not.

 

(Banner Photo: Aphexlee)

Philip Griffin    08 November 2011 12:02pm
The social utility of these holidays is a central point to make to your MPs I think.
We need to paint the picture of what this will mean: families will no longer be able to get together on Christmas Day/ Easter Day etc, as some of them will be serving customers at a retail outlet, and others will be called in to do some extra accounting or whatever to ensure the retailers can be open over these times.
Is that what Australians really want?

#2 of 9 top
Grant Hayes    08 November 2011 3:10pm
Whatever the rules about retail trading hours, there is nothing stopping Christians from keeping Christmas and Easter as times of reverent rest in their families and church communities, if that's what they really want to do.

Maybe the extension of retail activity to 24/7 could be seen by Christians as an opportunity to accentuate their witness as people of God's rest.

I can understand why denominations still devoted to the liturgical year and sacramental worship might contend for the legislative enforcement of Christmas and Easter holidays; it's part of their nostalgia for a waning, magisterial Christendom. But why would biblicist evangelicals contend for such times and seasons? There is virtually no scriptural warrant for Christmas and Easter as festivals. And good SydAngs should have no need for special holydays to concentrate their attention upon the incarnation, cross and resurrection. One day is as holy as the next, no?


#3 of 9 top
Philip Griffin    08 November 2011 3:17pm
You raise some excellent points Grant. I don't believe we need any special days or festivals of any kind at all. However, I do believe in the principle of rest, rest for individuals and for communities. Public Holidays provide for that. For me, it is the public utility of such days that commend them to the state as days to proscribe major retail activity etc.

#4 of 9 top
Grant Hayes    08 November 2011 3:51pm
I get your gist, Philip, and I, for one, don't want to see any further erosion of the public holidays we already have. Even so, there are not enough of them to facilitate the general public rest you identify (that would take something like ... a weekly Sabbath!) And the way these "days off" are treated by many Australians is not very conducive to restfulness anyway. In the case of Christmas, any "rest" on the day itself is overwhelmed by the increasingly frantic lead-up to it. And the escapist exodus of the Australian Easter (with attendant road-toll spike) is likewise an exercise in, well, more exercise.

Perhaps Christians could find ways of modelling regular restfulness to our 24/7, work hard/play hard, overfed, over-stimulated culture.

#5 of 9 top
Stephen Davis    09 November 2011 11:42am
Those people who want to spend Christmas day with their families should not be potentially forced not to because of these laws regardless of what their faith is. Christmas day is a day that reminds those who are believers that God sent his Son to redeem us. It does not get any simpler than that for Christians. On a more general side though, the parents of little children get an immense amount of joy out of seeing the smiles and happiness on their children's faces when they open their gifts and speaking from a parent's point of view, that is priceless, they cannot enjoy that little concession if they are stuck at work!

#6 of 9 top
Grant Hayes    09 November 2011 12:57pm
Stephen,
Christmas day is a day that reminds those who are believers that God sent his Son to redeem us. It does not get any simpler than that for Christians.

It's a relic from Christendom's old liturgical year, and has its origins in non-Christian religious festivals (of Sol Invictus/Helios-Mithras, also Saturnalia, plus pagan Yule - winter solstice, death/rebirth of the sun). The 25th of December (and its trappings) has no intrinsic connection with the Jesus of Scripture; it's all about sun worship in the Northern winter, overlaid with a veneer of sacramental (and sentimental) Christendom.

So how are you justified - as a "Bible-believing" evangelical - in holding this particular date to be especially blessed, unless you agree that the pagans were on to something ;^)

Christians can reflect on the incarnation any time they like; they don't need a state enforced, pagan-derived public holiday to do it. And they can arrange their working lives to spend quality time with their families any time they like (eg. annual leave). And they can give presents to their children any time they like.

Ah, but Christmas = Magic, and it would seem that even biblicist evangelicals have a hard time giving that up!

#7 of 9 top
Stephen Davis    09 November 2011 1:01pm
Grant - my short and honest answer - I really do not care! For me personally, it is another opportunity to reflect on what the Lord has done for me as well as the other thing I mentioned about families on Christmas day with their kids - it does not get any simpler than that.

#8 of 9 top
Grant Hayes    09 November 2011 1:16pm
None of these things have any necessary connection to the 25th December - it does not get any simpler than that.

#9 of 9 top
Stephen Davis    09 November 2011 1:20pm
OK, fine, Christians can really celebrate the birth of Jesus whenever they want. It is not a matter for salvation so it is not wise for Christians to make too big a deal of it.

#10 of 9 top
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.